Test Tool Comparison Matrix Essay

A defining factor for successfully applying test automation in software projects is choosing and using the right set of test automation tools. This is a daunting task, especially for those new to software test automation, because there are so many tools in the market to choose from, each having different strengths and weaknesses. There is no one tool that can fit all automated testing needs, which makes finding the right tool difficult. Learn how to identify the right automation tool for your project with this qualitative comparison popular automated testing toolsets in the market.

Overview of Tools

Katalon Studio is an automated testing platform that offers a comprehensive set of features to implement full automated testing solutions for mobile and web applications. Built on top of the open-source Selenium and Appium frameworks, Katalon allows teams to get started with test automation quickly by reducing the effort and expertise required for learning and integrating these frameworks for automated testing needs.

Selenium is the most popular automation framework that consists of many tools and plugins for Web application testing. Selenium is known for its powerful capability to support performance testing of Web applications. Selenium is the most popular choice in the open-source test automation space, partly due to its large and active development and user community.

HP Unified Functional Testing (UFT), formerly QuickTest Professional (QTP), is probably the most popular commercial tool for functional test automation. HP UFT offers a comprehensive set of features that can cover most functional automated testing needs on the desktop, mobile, and web platforms.

TestComplete is also a commercial integrated platform for desktop, mobile, and web application testing. Like UFT, TestComplete offers a number of key test automation features such as keyword-driven and data-driven testing, cross-browser testing, API testing, and CI integrations. This tool supports a number of languages including JavaScript, Python, VBScript, JScript, DelphiScript, C++Script, and C#Script for writing test scripts.

Comparison of Tools

The table below provides a comparison of the tools based on the key features of software automation:


Katalon Studio




Test development platform





Application under test

Web and mobile apps

Web apps

Windows desktop, web, mobile apps

Windows desktop, web, mobile apps

Scripting languages


Java, C#, Perl, Python, JavaScript, Ruby, PHP


JavaScript, Python, VBScript, JScript, Delphi, C++, and C#

Programming skills

Not required. Recommended for advanced test scripts

Advanced skills needed to integrate various tools

Not required. Recommended for advanced test scripts

Not required. Recommended for advanced test scripts

Learning curves





Ease of installation and use

Easy to set up and run

Require installing and integrating various tools

Easy to setup and run

Easy to setup and run

Script creation time





Object storage and maintenance

Built-in object repository, XPath, object re-identification

XPath, UI Maps

Built-in object repository, smart object detection and correction

Built-in object repository, detecting common objects

Image-based testing

Built-in support

Require installing additional libraries

Built-in support, image-based object recognition

Built-in support

Continuous integrations

Popular CI tools (e.g. Jenkins, Teamcity)

Various CI tools (e.g. Jenkins, Cruise Control)

Various CI tools (e.g. Jenkins, HP Quality Center)

Various CI tools (e.g. Jenkins, HP Quality Center)

Product support

Ticketing support, community

Open source community

Dedicated staff, community

Dedicated staff, community

License type


Open source (Apache 2.0)






License and maintenance fees

License and maintenance fees

Strengths and Weaknesses

Below is a summary of key strengths and limitations of the tools, based on the comparison above.




Katalon Studio               

No licensing and maintenance fees requires

Integrating necessary frameworks and features for quick test cases creation and execution.

Built on top of the Selenium framework but eliminating the need for advanced programming skills required for Selenium.

Emerging solution with a small community

Feature set is still evolving.

Lack of choices for scripting languages: only Java/Groovy is supported.


Open source, no licensing and maintenance fees

Large and active development and user community to keep pace with software technologies.

Open for integration with other tools and frameworks to enhance its capability

Testing teams need to have good programming skills and experience to setup and integrate Selenium with other tools and frameworks.

New teams need to invest time upfront for setup and integration

Slow support from the community.


Mature, comprehensive automated testing features integrated into a single system.

Dedicated user support plus an established large user community.

Requiring only basic programming skills to get started with test creation and execution.

Costly solution: license and maintenance fees are considerably high.

Possible high costs for upgrades and additional modules.

Supporting only VBScript.


Mature, comprehensive automated testing features integrated into a single system.

Many scripting languages to choose from.

Only basic programming skills needed.

Like UFT, considerable licensing and maintenance fees needed for TestComplete.

There is no one-size-fits-all tool for automated testing. It is highly recommended that testers evaluate various tools in order to select what would best meet their automated testing needs. Programming languages and technologies used to develop software continue to evolve, as do the automated testing tools, making cost a significant factor in tool selection. Commercial vendors often charge for tool upgrades, which can be substantial if your software uses emerging and frequently changing technologies. Open source and non-commercial tools, on the other hand, do not incur additional charges, but require effort and expertise for integrating new upgrades. It is difficult to find the support and expertise needed for integrating various tools and frameworks into open-source solutions. Emerging tools that integrate with open-source frameworks, like Katalon, offer a viable alternative to both commercial and open-source automated testing solutions.

Test Management encompasses anything and everything that we do as testers and we take help of the best and the efficient test management software to perform this task.

Our day-to-day activities include:

  1. Creating and maintaining release /project cycle /component information
  2. Creating and maintaining the test artifacts specific to each release /cycle that we have- requirements, test cases, etc.
  3. Establishing traceability and coverage between the test assets
  4. Test execution support – test suite creation, test execution status capture, etc.
  5. Metric collection/report-graph generation for analysis
  6. Bug tracking/defect management

The above are broadly some of the tasks that involve what we call, the test management process. This process is critical, detail-oriented and instrumental is making sure that the entire testing effort is successful. 

Well, the good news is, there is help available. Through this

Through this article, we will try to introduce ourselves to the most commonly available tools for the test management process briefly. Here is the

Here is the comparison of top test management software.


=>> Let us knowif you want to add any other tool in this list.


What You Will Learn:

List of the Best Test Management Tools of 2018:

  1. qTest
  2. PractiTest
  3. Zephyr
  4. Test Collab
  5. TestFLO for JIRA
  6. XQual
  7. TestCaseLab
  8. QAComplete
  9. QACoverage
  10. Plutora Test
  11. Inflectra
  12. Meliora Testlab
  13. TestMonitor
  14. Panaya

Let’s start!

1) qTest:

It’s no surprise why qTest is the #1 test management tool amongst Agile testing & QA teams. qTest provides software testing and development teams with an easy to learn, easy to use, lightning fast, scalable test management that seamlessly integrates with JIRA, other ALMs, and automation tools. qTest has proven to make every step of the QA process faster, simpler and more efficient:

Manage Requirements, Test case repository, Test Execution, Defect Tracking, Reporting, and Integrations.

qTest is one of fastest growing test management solutions on the market today amongst Agile testing and development teams. Be sure to add it to your short list of test management tools to trial

Visit qTest website – Try qTest test management free


2) PractiTest:

An entirely SaaS end-to-end QA and Agile friendly Test management tool. Using their unique and customizable filters you can efficiently organize your requirements, create and run tests, track bugs and generate reports using this tool. It integrates seamlessly with leading bug tracking tools like JIRA, Pivotal Tracker, Bugzilla, and Redmine as well as various automation tools such as Selenium, Jenkins etc. However, their API can ensure further customizing for your process’ needs.

It is not open source but is quite affordable. You can benefit from their human methodological support throughout your usage.

Visit PractiTest website:PractiTest For more features and pricing information.


3) Zephyr:

Zephyr is the #1 selling testing solution with more than 11,000 global customers (and growing) in 100+ countries, with over 20 million tests executed.

Zephyr offers innovative applications and unparalleled, real-time visibility into the quality and status of software projects. Integrate tools your teams are already using today such as JIRA, Selenium, QTP/UFT, Bamboo, Jenkins, Confluence and so much more via well-documented REST APIs. Their feature-rich products address today’s dynamic and global needs across a variety of industries including finance, healthcare, media, mobile, IT services, and enterprise software.

Visit Zephyr website: Start your FREE trial of Zephyr for JIRA today!


4) Test Collab:

Test Collab is a modern test management tool which offers a complete platform for your application’s testing. It offers state-of-the-art integration with all popular bug trackers and test automation tools. Apart from that, it offers time tracking,  agile methodology, requirements management, test plans and scheduling.

Visit Test Collab website for free trial and more info: Test Collab


5) TestFLO for JIRA


TestFLO is JIRA add-on providing comprehensive test management process into JIRA due to reusable Repository of Test Cases allowing for rapid Test Plan creation and copying.

TestFLO supports flexible configurations for Agile Teams and Projects, smoothly integrates with defects and requirements providing broad traceability metrics and extensive reporting including all JIRA metrics and statistics. TestFLO integrates with CI tools like Jenkins or Bamboo for automated tests allowing you to run tests from JIRA and publish test results in real-time.

Visit TestFLO website: For more features and free trial, check TestFLO website.


6) XQual

XQual delivers one of the most advanced/complete Test Management solutions for a very light pricing. From this unique tool, you’ll be able to manage not less than your releases, requirements, risks, specifications, tests, campaigns and bugs.

It can be integrated with all the continuous integration platforms and it can drive ANY kind of test: 5 different interfaces for manual testing and nearly 70 connectors for all the best automation frameworks on the market: Selenium, QTP/UFT, JMeter, Ranorex, TestComplete, JUnit, NUnit, TestPartner, Sahi, NeoLoad, QF-Test, RobotFramework, Sikuli, SoapUi, Squish, TestNg, TestOptimal and many more.

It includes an internal requirement and bug-tracking management module but it can be integrated with many third-party requirements or bug-tracking systems (i.e. JIRA, ClearQuest, Mantis etc.).

Try it for one month here: XQual


7) TestCaseLab

Powered by Gera-IT company, TestCaseLab is a web-based case management tool released in April 2016. You may easily manage your manual test cases, apply and modify different properties, gather them in test plans and form test runs in one single location. It has the full set of required features wrapped into the great user interface. Supported integrations: JIRA, Redmine, Pivotal Tracker.

Competitive pricing plans and absence of plaguesome quantitive limitations will let you easily start your activities and boost the performance of your QA team.

Visit TestCaseLab website:TestCaseLab


8) QAComplete

QAComplete is a powerful, flexible test management tool that helps users easily manage requirements, tests and defects all in one place. The tool is easy to use, and provides a central hub to manage and report on all of your tests – manual, Selenium, TestComplete, SoapUI and more!

It is customizable enough to fit into any development process, from Waterfall to Agile, and integrates tightly with the project management and workflow tools you already use, such as Jira, Bugzilla, Visual Studio and more.

Visit QAComplete website:QAComplete


9) QACoverage

QACoverage is a cost-effective, new generation test management solution with innovative vision and workflow to manage Software Test Life Cycles more effectively and efficiently. It boosts test productivity and provides visibility to better handle and control your established QA process via comprehensive Agile, Requirements Management, Test Design, Test Execution, Defects Management, and Metrics & Reporting modules.

QACoverage is not only a Test Management Solution but a collaborative platform that integrates the entire IT Department throughout the Software Development Life Cycle from requirements inception to application production readiness in order to achieve superior quality.

Visit QACoverage Website:Try a free 30 days QA Coverage trial


10) Plutora Test

Plutora Test is a modern, enterprise test management tool that supports the complete software testing process across all types of development methodologies from traditional Waterfall to Continuous Delivery approaches.

It uses a single instance for all projects consolidating testing design, planning, manual and automated execution, defect tracking and progress reporting and improves efficiency every step of the way. Integration is provided for all related tools and systems, such as Jira and Selenium.

It engages stakeholders and drives collaboration between teams with analytics, metrics, and reporting capabilities not found in any other tool. It is highly customizable adapting to individual teams while still providing a single view across all teams.

Organizations using legacy systems can easily upgrade to the SaaS Platform in just a few clicks using the Bulk Upload feature in Plutora Testincorporate existing requirements, user stories, and test cases.

Visit Plutora Website:Get a Free 30 Evaluation


11) SPIRATEST by Inflectra

SpiraTest is a feature-rich test management solution that helps users manage all of their tests, requirements, and bugs in one place.

All your tests work together: everything from continuous integration, to unit tests, automation tests, and manual testing.

Right out of the box, SpiraTest is designed to integrate seamlessly with industry best practices and lets you fully tailor it to your needs. Particularly welcome is the generous pricing structure – based on concurrent logins, not the number of registered users.

SpiraTest- Crazy Fast Testing!

Visit SpiraTest Website:Enjoy your 30-day free trial here


12) Meliora Testlab

Meliora Testlab is a modern, easy to approach Test management tool that has features to master test management for projects from small to big.

The tool supports manual and automated testing in unique way to give a clear view on quality of the system being developed – with no overhead on reporting tasks.

Meliora Testlab is also a full ALM tool with requirements and issue tracking modules. The tool also integrates to most important CI and Issue trackers etc.

Visit Meliora Testlab Website: Here is the SaaS trial link


13) TestMonitor

TestMonitor is the most user-friendly test management tool perfect for Agile and traditional test teams. Easy to use SaaS product with integrated issue management. Fully compliant with ISTQB® and TMap NEXT® testing methods.

Ensure quality based on requirements, risks, status, impact and other predefined project metrics. Custom filtering gives your team the option to track and report the metrics you choose. Easily integrated with JIRA or other bug tracker tools via Zapier.

Full power test management with usability in mind, a simple interface built for end-users and test professionals.

Visit Testmonitor website:Try Testmonitor for Free


14) Panaya Test Center

Panaya Test Center is a test acceleration platform that helps organizations Accelerate and standardize packaged application testing without compromising on scope or quality.

By encompassing the needs of all stakeholders and integrating standardized testing processes for both technical IT and Business users, Panaya reduces overall testing effort by 30-50%. Powered by machine learning capabilities, Panaya Autonomous Testing for SAP eliminates the pains associated with creating and maintaining manually engineered scripts and enables zero-touch test case creation and maintenance.

Visit Panaya website:Panaya Test Center


15) JIRA

JIRA is a tool that makes an appearance anytime there is a discussion on any management process – for all the right reasons. JIRA has 2 add-ons that support the test management process.

  a) Zephyr: All the aspects that you would expect of a typical tool of this type are supported. You can create tests/test suites/test cycles/bugs/reports and so on. You could have an additional add-on, ZAPI for automation integration.  Along with the initial JIRA license, you would have to pay for Zephyr to use it. ($10 for 10 users a month).

  b) Go2Group SynapseRT: This tool has all the test management features but the primary focus is on requirement based testing. It can be used for projects where it makes more sense to track your progress in terms of the completion and/or success-failure of a certain requirement as opposed to testing cases. Traceability is of higher priority with this add-on. Along with the initial JIRA license, you would have to pay for this add-on too. ($10 for 10 users a month).


16) TestRail:

TestRail is a centralized test case management tool – you can use it to create test cases and test suites, track execution, and report metrics. Additionally, it integrates with many issue tracking tools that make requirements from external systems to be linked to test cases in TestRail; bugs can also be created with the external systems and links can be established to the corresponding test case. It comes with the HTTP-based API to integrate with the automated test results. One most common integration is with Gemini, which is an incident/ticket management system (supports agile too). It is a commercial product with a free trial available here.

17) TestLodge:

This is a comprehensive test case management tool that has 4 key aspects – Test Plan, requirements, Test suites/cases and test runs. So, as you can see, it has everything it needs to be able to manage test cases for you. For all the other operations, it integrates with the many mainstream incident/issue management tools to provide a comprehensive solution. It is a commercial product, for a free trial visit here.

18) HP ALM/Quality center:

HP QC has been one of the most used test management software for many years. It has all the features necessary and in many ways, it is the standard against which the other tools are measured. Even though it is one of the high-end tools, economically, it still remains to be very popular. Check out this page for trial and other information.

19) QMetry:

QMetry is the most comprehensive Digital Quality Platform designed for agile testing and DevOps teams to build, manage, and deploy quality software faster with confidence. QMetry provides the agile testing solution with complete test management, test automation, powerful quality metrics and analytics.  The tool is widely used across enterprises in BFSI, Hardware, Technology, Healthcare, Education and other industry verticals. Request for a Free Trial and Free Demo.

20) Testuff:

Testuff is Saas Test Management tool that has many cool features. The typical test case management features are a given. Besides that, it has a cool video upload capability for a defect. Integrates with a huge list of bug-trackers, some of which are, Bugzilla, JIRA, YouTrack, Mantis among others. It has an API that supports automation tools like QTP, Rational Robot, Selenium, TestComplete etc. Best of all, it is very affordable. Check out the features and pricing information here.

21) Gemini:

One of the key components of this tool is supporting ‘Testing & QA’ along with the other aspects like Project Planning, issue tracking etc. Using this tool you could create test plans, test cases, test runs, traceability, test run reports etc. There are also various integrations and extensions available. It is a commercial product with a free starter pack available here.

22) TestLink:

This is one of the very few open source test management tools available for use in the market.  It is a web-based tool with typical features like requirement management, test case creation, and maintenance, test runs, tracking bugs, reports, integration with common issue trackers etc. To download, visit this page.

23) Silk Central:

This is a test management product by Borland. Once you have Silk Central with you there is a nothing left for you to ask for anything else. It is robustness personified, though it is pricey.  All the features for coverage, traceability, reporting, test creation, running – it has got them.  It integrates with many source control and issue tracking systems. There are additional plug-ins to extend its capabilities to automation testing using QTP, WinRunner etc. It comes with a video capture feature and supports SAP testing. This product is really cool. Try it here.

24) IBM Rational Quality Manager

A test Management product that has all the typical features – Test planning, test design, test execution, tracking, and reporting. It integrates with many of the rational products for automation, source control, and bug tracking activities. It is a commercial product. Check out its features, pricing and other information here.


Additional tools:

The below are some more tools that are worth mentioning:

25) VersionOne: A commercial product primarily catering to agile projects, this has a test management module along with planning, reporting, and others, with all the typical features. Check it out here.

26) TestPad:  This tool’s motto is “Spend more time actually testing”. The primary concept of this tool is – checklists. In your test plan, you could have a series of checklists (tests) that can be as detailed or as short as possible. It is perfect for exploratory testing. It is commercial and you can try it here.

27) Aptest: a web-based, commercial product that has all the typical features you would expect along with the typical integrations with issue trackers. Check it here.

28) SpiraTest: A complete QA solution is what this product is. Instead of having your requirements, tests, defects in separate systems, this tool has it all in one place. It integrates with unit and automation testing frameworks among other things. It is commercial, though not very expensive. More details.

29)Meliora TestLab: This is a simple to use the product for requirement management, test-creating & running, defect management, workflow optimization, and integration with JIRA etc.  Commercial again, check it.

30) SmarteQM:A complete lifecycle management tool that provides the complete end-to-end test process support and integrates with other SmartSoft functional test tools.  It is web-based and commercial. Details.

31)Test Run:  a web-based commercial test management process that is easy and simple to use. It has all that you need to create test plans, execute them successfully and report. Integrates with JIRA and LightHouse. More details.

32) Test Wave:A test management tool that needs no installation, is web-based, simple and commercial (affordable). This tool provides you with a facility to import your already existing requirements/test assets from excel sheets. It also comes with an inbuilt defect tracker. Check here.

33) Enterprise Tester: This test management tool supports both agile and traditional projects. Integrates with JIRA and also works great for automation testing with QTP, Selenium, RFT etc. This is a really cool commercial tool. Check it out here.

34)TestLog: A very comprehensive end-to-end test management tool that is easy to install and configure due to its XML database. It allows documentation of both automation and manual test cases. It also comes with a web interface for remote access.  This product is commercial too.

35)QaTraq:  An open source test process control tool that can be used to create test cases, running them, recording results etc. Check here.

Points to note:

Well, from the above list two things are apparent:

  1. There are not many open source tools of this type available, although most of them are still affordable.
  2. Most of the tools just provide test case management and leave the bug tracking to be integrated via an external tool. (A smart choice, if you ask me. Otherwise, all of us would be stuck reinventing the wheel.)


Even though we put up a big list, we realize that we could not have included every tool available.

Share your experiences with the best test management tools – both the ones that made it to the list and those which did not- with us below.

We hope this list comes in handy to you when in search for a tool that fits your needs and we can’t wait to hear your comments, suggestions, additions, and of course, appreciations. :)


=>> Let us know if you want to add any other tool in this list.



Categories: 1

0 Replies to “Test Tool Comparison Matrix Essay”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *